Can an image be technically perfect but emotionally lacking?

Question

Steve Brazill · Answer

Can an image be technically, perfect, but emotionally lacking. Yes, I'd argue a lot of images are, if not most because most images are snapshots, right? Most images are pictures where somebody use the gear properly, they understood technically how to operate the camera, how to get focus. And if it was on a phone, the camera did the autofocus. They understood white balance again phone. Probably did the white balance form and maybe just from their life, they understand subconsciously. Lee a couple of good compositional rules and managed to capture a composition that works to the strengths of the image, but getting an emotionally. Impactful image is much more than that. It's more than just following the recipe. I'll give you an example. If you're in the kitchen, we all know somebody that's gotten a really good recipe from a family member and they go into the kitchen and they try and make that recipe and they follow it to the T. And at the end they say that doesn't taste like Like my mom's, but they followed it perfectly. It's technically perfect to the instructions in the way, the equipment was supposed to be used, but what they don't know. Is mom had a slight bit of artistic Vision, she put a pinch in here and there, she had her own artistic voice and that goes beyond the technical. Thanks for the question.

Tony Sweet · Answer

The question is, can an image be technically perfect? But emotionally lacking, of course. Anything in the Arts can be like that music. I play music for 25 years, you know. And there are many musicians, I know personally who are technically like perfect but they're they're feel is sterile there's no emotion to those. Just focused on technicality to me, I like a little imperfection in the earth, it has it has a human element. Into it. It has to the emotionality of the image because it is slightly imperfect, you know? So of course, these can be Tennessee, perfect and emotionally lacking, they could also be typically imperfect and emotionally profound. It depends on everything but the answer is yes. Absolutely. And image can be technically perfect and emotionally lacking.

Charlie Hamilton James · Answer

Can an image be technically, perfect, but emotionally laughing. Absolutely. I think, you know, it's a wildlife photographer. I see so many images and people's work, which is technically perfect. But says, we're just create no feeling of anything in, you? You look at anything. Wow, that's pain sharp. That's nice light, but it doesn't necessarily mean there's any emotion in it, and I've worked with photographers, who very technically, very good photographers but there were definitely lacks emotion. And the problem of the motion is it's very hard to figure out exactly what it is and how it works within the image. But when it's there, it's, you know, it's the most powerful important part of the image. So, yeah, I think, you know, we all have to work out technically how our cameras work and master them, but that's just a small step on the way to taking really good photos. And Good photos. Their number one element, is emotion.

Ryan Moss · Answer

Can image be technically perfect, but emotionally lacking. I would I haven't listened to what other said. I kind of didn't want to be persuaded by anyone else in my answer. I think if image is technically perfect. I think That's that in itself. The fact that you realize and time to notice that secondly imperfect is emotion because you're obviously curious enough to look at the image further to make sure it is technically perfect. It Also I guess is captivating and away when an image is completely technically perfect. And you know, it's something we all aspire to do is photographers to you know, everytime take a technically Perfect Image. So Yes, probably in the sense that you know, you're you're not getting sensation of fear pain. Joy in the traditional sense, it can be lacking, but I think Almost every image that is technically perfectly shot. probably evoke some sort of emotion from a person, whether it's, you know, the traditional sense or, you know, just like I don't know. I don't know. I don't know if like is profound thought. It's like thinking profoundly. And that sense I was that like emotion. I don't know, I don't know if that's a thing. I would love to hear from other people and I actually probably not listen to their answers right after I get off this one.

Moose Peterson · Answer

Oh boy. I like this question. Can image be technically, perfect, but emotionally lacking. Oh man. Can it you see examples of this every day? I've said, for a long time, but the world doesn't need is more technically perfect photographs. The world needs more photographs with emotions and yeah, it's, you know, and that's the scary thing about a photographer. Tha graffiti is that promotion of being a photograph, you had to put your emotion in the photograph. And that means you have Put yourself out there and that's a big risk because I'm telling you, some people aren't going to like the photographs, which then you kind of can interpret us. They don't like your emotions and that takes you down a rabbit hole. So yeah, they're technically perfect is not the measure for a good photograph.

Philip Platzer · Answer

Yes, for sure. 100%. It's these days, especially these days. It's super easy to get technical perfect images, but when everything else is missing like composition or the moment itself, the emotion in it, it's not a good photography. So yeah, it happened to meet at a almost deleted pictures on camera because I wasn't happy with the with the quality. Like it was little bit blurrier. And in the end it it was Go to show the no one really cared about this. Slight blur with his technical imperfect imperfectness. So always always put emotion over the technical aspect that would recommend

Swimming

Strength

Triathlon

Photography

Track & Field

Nutrition

Physical Therapy

Running

Pets

Cycling

Podcasting

HealthCare

Musculoskeletal

Hockey

First Responders

Integrative Medicine

Chiropractic

Cross Country Skiing

Adaptive Sports

Climbing

Mental Health

Surfing

Tennis

Military

Mind Body

Scholars

Criminal Justice

Liquor

CrossFit

Golf

Soccer

Pickleball

Hunting

Public Speaking

Venture Capital

"Can an image be technically perfect but emotionally lacking?"